S2TEM Centers SC

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Locations
    • Staff
  • Grants
  • We Offer
    • Continuing Education Courses
    • Disciplinary Literacy Support
    • Instructional Coaching
    • Instructional Leadership
    • STEM School Support
  • Resources
    • Disciplinary Literacy Virtual Library >
      • Math Lessons
      • Science Lessons
      • Self-Paced Learning Modules
      • Strategy Warehouse
      • Training Guides
    • SC Standards Support Documents
    • Standard Support System (S3) - UPDATED
    • Standard Support System (S3) >
      • Biology Lessons
      • Elementary Algebra Lessons
      • K-8 Mathematics Lessons
      • K-8 Science Lessons
      • Physical Science Lessons
    • State and National Conference Presentations
    • STEM Innovation Configuration (IC) Maps
    • STEM Theory of Action >
      • Assessment
      • Collaboration
      • Continuous Learning
      • Curriculum
      • Data
      • Engaged Community
      • Innovation
      • Instructional Support
      • Professional Learning
      • STEM for All
  • Connect
    • Blog
    • Facebook
    • Newsletter
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • STEMLinx
  • S2TEM Family
    • 4H-Science on the Move
    • Charleston STEM Fest
    • D.I.G.
    • ìMAGINE Upstate
    • Lowcountry STEM Collaborative
    • Next Steps Institute
    • SC Afterschool Alliance
    • SC Coalition for Mathematics & Science
    • STEM Education Summit
    • This School's Got STEM
    • Upstate SC STEM Collaborative
  • Donate
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Locations
    • Staff
  • Grants
  • We Offer
    • Continuing Education Courses
    • Disciplinary Literacy Support
    • Instructional Coaching
    • Instructional Leadership
    • STEM School Support
  • Resources
    • Disciplinary Literacy Virtual Library >
      • Math Lessons
      • Science Lessons
      • Self-Paced Learning Modules
      • Strategy Warehouse
      • Training Guides
    • SC Standards Support Documents
    • Standard Support System (S3) - UPDATED
    • Standard Support System (S3) >
      • Biology Lessons
      • Elementary Algebra Lessons
      • K-8 Mathematics Lessons
      • K-8 Science Lessons
      • Physical Science Lessons
    • State and National Conference Presentations
    • STEM Innovation Configuration (IC) Maps
    • STEM Theory of Action >
      • Assessment
      • Collaboration
      • Continuous Learning
      • Curriculum
      • Data
      • Engaged Community
      • Innovation
      • Instructional Support
      • Professional Learning
      • STEM for All
  • Connect
    • Blog
    • Facebook
    • Newsletter
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • STEMLinx
  • S2TEM Family
    • 4H-Science on the Move
    • Charleston STEM Fest
    • D.I.G.
    • ìMAGINE Upstate
    • Lowcountry STEM Collaborative
    • Next Steps Institute
    • SC Afterschool Alliance
    • SC Coalition for Mathematics & Science
    • STEM Education Summit
    • This School's Got STEM
    • Upstate SC STEM Collaborative
  • Donate

A Barrier Overcome:  Residencies for Teachers

10/24/2016

 

There is an awkwardly located pothole in the road that leads students from their professional education in college to a successful teaching career.  The budding teacher has sailed through the content courses, the education specific classes like ed. psych, the instructional methods and clinical experience, but nothing has prepared the new teacher for the first year in a classroom. 

As Goodman (2012) reports, the literature on first-year teachers has been very consistent about the problems they face.

First, teachers with three or fewer years of experience are challenged by the difficulties of managing student behavior.  

The next challenge is curricular.  The teacher knows her subject but she has little guidance about what parts of the subject should be taught to her students.  Almost half (41%) of Teach for America teachers reported that neither the district nor their school provided useful instructional resources like lesson plans.  Case studies of new teachers show them spending many hours trying to "come up with enough curriculum"  and then struggling with how to teach it all the while juggling all the other duties, including paperwork, committees, after school clubs and so forth.  (Goodman, 2012)

The "sink-or-swim" challenges of classroom behavior and the mystery of curriculum are exacerbated by a professional of catch-22:  in order to become accepted the new teacher must demonstrate that she is good at precisely those things she has the most difficulty with--managing her classroom and successful instruction!

So new teachers report "difficult interactions with colleagues, from neglect by administrators to lack of cooperation or even hostility from veteran teachers." (Goodman, 2012)

The new teacher's struggles are often a disaster for his or her students who are likely to do more poorly than their peers being taught by more experienced teachers.  

Teaching is a profession which means that solutions to the dilemma of inexperienced teachers must be professional solutions that give the neophyte professional experiences.  The accomplished physician, lawyer, or teacher has, in addition to content knowledge about medicine, law, or pedagogy, what Lee Shulman called "the wisdom of practice."

How do professionals acquire the wisdom of practice?  New teachers often respond to the challenges posed by their inexperience by developing survival rather than professional skills.  A lecture appears to be a better approach to instruction than a project with its potential for losing control of the classroom.  

A way to prepare the new teacher so that developing professional skills rather than survival skills has been found in the adaptation of one developed in medical education, the residency.  In the early 20th century, medical education was revived when medical schools affiliated themselves with hospitals and added a multi-year residency in which the newly graduated physician treated patients under the guidance of accomplished physicians who were both medical school faculty as well as being on the staff of the hospital.  

An historian of medical educaiton observed that the educational power of the residency lay in "...the quality of the house officers and faculty, the characteristics of the teaching, giving residents the opportunity to assume responsibility in patient management, the availability of time to reflect and wonder, the opportunity for residents to establish meaningful personal relationships with faculty, patients, and each other, the provision of manageable patient loads, freeing residents from too many extraneous chores, holding high expectations of residents, and conducting residency training in an atmosphere of professional excitement."  (Bank Street, 2016)

In fact, the year-long teacher residency is not something new.  Programs already exist in which teacher training programs and school districts and schools are providing new teachers with year-long residencies.  

The Louisiana Department of Education has devoted 2% of its budget to support the Believe and Prepare partnerships "to create stronger clinical preparation experiences."  According to the report, 60% of Louisiana school districts and 80% of preparation providers have voluntarily partnered in order for "aspiring teachers to work with skilled mentors before they can earn an initial teaching certificate."  (Bank Street, 2016)

U.S. Prep, a program developed at Texas Tech has impressive results with a 90% job retention rate of the teachers who have gone through the program.  

According to Karen Demoss, the programs like U.S. Prep are important because they help bridge the chasm fro the young teacher.  Working in a supportive environment with an accomplished teacher gives the neophyte educator the chance for a successful initial year, for both teachers and, even more importantly, for their students.  "Students in classrooms with residents have been documented to make larger learning gains than those in other classrooms, with strongest benefits going to those with the most need.  Residency graduates are also more effective teachers.  Rigorous studies have documented how their students outperform peers."  (Demoss, 2016)

The report "For the Public Good" both describes exemplary teacher residencies and also provides ideas about how to fund such programs.  

"For the Public Good" makes the case that if one examines the various funding streams available to states and their districts, it is possible to create a priority list with the year-long teacher residency high on the list given its importance for both beginning teachers andd the students they will teach during a long career.  

There are funds built-in to the current system to remedy problems that result from inadequate teacher preparation that could be reinvested to support residencies.  Teacher turnover costs school districts about $2.2 billion per year.  There are also the costs that result from students who have experienced an ineffective teacher, such as costs for remedial summer school, tutoring, or students dropping out of school altogether.  

Districts can be thoughtful.  For example, a district might use a portion of the current budget for substitute teachers to hire a promising new graduate who would work four days a week co-teaching with an accomplished veteran leaving one day free when the resident teacher could serve as a substitute where needed. 

As the state level Every Student Succeeds Act makes it possible to dedicate up to 5% of its Title II part A (professional development) funds to create competitive grants to colleges of education and public school districts to create model residency programs.  

Teacher residency may appear to be an expensive luxury; failure to fully prepare teachers makes the luxury into a necessity.  

Resources:
Demoss, Karen (2016).  Five reasons teacher residencies often outperform traditional training. The Hechinger Report.

Goodwin, Bryan (2012). Research Says/ New Teachers Face Three Common Challenges. Educational Leadership May 2012 (69:8) Supporting Beginning Teachers Pages 84-85. 

The Bank Street College of Education (2016). For the Public Good: Quality Preparation for Every Teacher. 



    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Picture

    Dr. John Holton

    Dr. John Holton joined the S²TEM Centers SC in July of 2013, as a research associate with an emphasis on the STEM literature including state and local STEM plans from around the nation.

    Archives

    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016

    Categories

    All
    00 Proteins Encoded In The Human Genome
    20
    Accelerometers
    Accountability
    Active Learning
    Adaptation
    Advanced Placement
    Africa
    A.I. And Art
    Albert Einstein
    Algeria
    Alison Gopnik
    Allan Wilson
    Andrew Wakefield
    Anti-vaxxer Movement
    Arbovirus
    Archaea
    Architecture
    Arrhythmia
    Arthur Eddington
    Artificial Intelligence
    Art Museum-medical School Partnerships
    Astronomy
    Atrial Fibrillation
    Autism
    Background Knowledge
    Bacteria
    Barry Barish
    Bias
    Biodiversity
    Biology
    Biomimicry
    Biomolecules
    Bottom-up Model
    Brain
    Breakthrough Model Of Science
    Brian Deer
    Bruce Heezen
    Bucket List
    Caltech
    Cambridge
    Carbon
    Carbon Dioxide
    Cardiogram
    Career
    Carl Woese
    Charles Darwin
    Charles Eliot
    Charleston
    Charter Schools
    Chemical Fires
    Chicago Public Schools
    Child Development
    Chirality
    Circadian Cycle
    Citizen Science
    Clarice Payne
    Climate Change
    Clinical Practice
    Cognitive Psychology
    Cognitive Science
    Cognitive Style
    Columbus
    Common Core
    Complex Vs Complicated
    Computer Screen Light
    Coronary Vascular Disease
    Cosmology
    Curriculum
    Custom Biomolecules
    Daniel T. Willingham
    Dark Energy
    Dark Matter
    Darwin
    David Baker
    David L. Goldberg
    Dermal Bone
    Disruption
    Dissymmetry
    Distortion Of Space-time
    DNA
    Domains
    Drainage Systems
    Dr. Michael Mann
    Early Childhood
    Early Learning
    Early Research Experience
    Ecology
    Economy
    Education
    Educational Technology
    Embryo
    E=mc^2
    Emile Zuckerkandl
    Endochondral Bone
    Engineering Is Elementary
    Enrico Fermi
    Environment
    Environments
    Epidemiology
    Ernest Rutherford
    Ernst Haeckel
    Eukarya
    Eukaryotes
    Every Student Succeeds Act
    Evidence-based Reading Strategies
    Evolution
    Exploration
    Extinction Events
    Finland
    First Robotics
    First Woman Department Chair
    First Woman Professor
    Fitness
    Formal Education
    Fossil Fuel
    Framingham Heart Study
    Gender Equality
    Gene
    General Knowledge
    General Relativity
    Genes
    Genetics
    Genome
    Geological Periods
    Global Warming
    Golden Theorem
    Google Translate
    Gravitational Waves
    Gravity
    Gravity Waves
    Great Global Rift
    Greenhouse Gases
    Growth Mindset
    Guided Tour
    Hans Van Meegeren
    Harlow Shapely
    Harvard
    Health
    Health EHeart
    Heart Disease
    Helium
    High-capacity Pumps
    History
    History Of Science
    Homework
    How Not To Be Wrong
    How Not To Be Wrong: The Power Of Mathematical Thinking
    Hox Genes
    Human Assessment
    Human Evolution
    Humboldt
    Hydrogen
    Hyperthyroidism
    Hypothyroidism
    Illness
    Indiana
    Innovation
    Inquiry
    Institute For Protein Design
    Interferometer
    Iodine
    Iron
    Jean Piaget
    Jenner
    Jet Lag
    Jordan Ellenberg
    Kelvin
    King Tides
    Kip Thorne
    Knowledge Capital
    Laboratory Science
    Law Of Large Numbers
    Learning
    Learning Communities
    Lifelong Learning
    Limbs
    Linus Pauling
    Logical Fallacy
    LOGO
    Long-term Memory
    Louisiana
    Louis Pasteur
    Lunar Eclipse
    Lunar Node
    Lunar Orbit
    Lynn Margulis
    Magnetometers
    Marie Tharp
    Marvin Minsky
    Massachusetts
    Math Anxiety
    Mathematical Thinking
    Mathematics
    Measles
    Mechanics Of Eclipse
    Medical Education
    Melatonin
    Mentor
    Miami
    Mice
    MIchigan
    Microbes
    Microbiome
    Mid-Ocean Ridges
    Mildred Desselhaus
    Mirror Images
    MIT
    MMR Vaccine
    Moon Distance From Earth
    Mosquitoes
    Mumps
    Nanotubes
    National Medal Of Science
    Natural Selection
    Nature
    Nature Of Science
    Neurons
    Neuroscience
    New Math
    Newnham College
    New York
    Niurnal
    Nobel Prize
    Non-superposable
    Norway
    Nuisance Flooding
    Observation
    Ohio
    Organisms
    Origin Of Species
    Paris Exhibition Of 1900
    Parochial Schools
    Pearl River Building
    Periodic Table
    Permian
    Personal Computers
    Pharmaceutical Manufacture
    Photoactive
    Physics
    Pineal Gland
    Plane Of Orbit
    Plate Tectonics
    Play
    Poisoning The Well
    Private Schools
    Project-based Curriculum
    Prokaryotes
    Protein Folding
    Proteins
    Proximity Sensors
    Public Schools
    Radiolaria
    Rainer Weiss
    Raising Streets
    Raman Effect
    Reading Comprehension
    Red Hills Of Kansas
    Rene Binet
    Rosalyn Yalow
    Rosetta Commons
    Rosetta Computing Platform
    Rubella
    SC Biology Standards
    School Choice
    School Reform
    Scientific Networks
    Scientific Processes
    Sean Reardon
    Sensors
    Sharing Computer Processing Power
    Short-term Memory
    Shubin
    Siberian Traps
    Sleep
    Smallpox
    Small Pox
    Social Studies
    Solar Eclipse
    South Carolina
    Space-time
    Special Relativity
    Spectrometer
    Speed Of Moon's Shadow On Earth
    Sputnik
    Stanford Center For Education Policy
    Stanford Education Data Archive
    STEAM
    Stellar Interiors
    STEM
    STEM Attrition
    Storm Water Management
    Strange Universe
    Stroke
    Sun
    Sunshine Flooding
    Sustainable Funding
    Tartaric Acid
    Tate Britain
    Teacher Preparation
    Teacher Residency
    Test Scores
    Tetrapods
    The Ethics Of Belief
    The Folding Problem
    The Great Dying
    The Harvard Classics
    The Lancet
    The Math-science Death March
    The Queen Of Carbon
    The Right To Believe
    The Sustainable Funding Project
    Thinking
    Thyroid
    Top-down Model Of Medicine
    Transition From Ocean To Land
    Transmission
    Triassic
    Types Of Private Schools
    Urban Ecosystem
    U.S. Department Of Education
    Vera Rubin
    Vermeer
    Virtual Neurons
    Vouchers
    Walter W. Crosby
    White-footed Mouse
    William Bennett
    Wk-clifford
    Women
    Women-in-science
    Women In STEM Careers
    Working Memory
    Workplace
    World Economic Forum Gender Equality Rating
    Zebrafish
    Zika

Picture
S²TEM Centers SC is an innovation partnership managed by South Carolina’s Coalition for Mathematics & Science at Clemson University.  Its purpose is to serve South Carolina by growing the Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) possibilities and capabilities of learners and leaders.

Copyright © S²TEM Centers SC 2018
Contact Us
✕